native esperanto speakers reddit

The comedian Spike Milligan is credited with the sentence “I speak Esperanto like a native”. I will say that learning Esperanto has taught me how to think like a language learner. ôéa-to live. XD. If only it had been German. The other two Esperanto native speakers from the video may join us later. I wish I were! If you have more questions, they will do an AMA later today. Before that, I don't see any problem, there is no way you could make a "neutral" childhood experience for your kids. It would work very easily because Slavs (when willing to ofc!) On the other hand, speakers of French and Romanian would have a very hard time to understand each other (dunno about written text though). Since it's easier to pick up and start using, I got a chance to make the really dumb mistakes early on and realize not to do things like: Don't insert "is", "am", etc. Yes that is it. Leo's Japanese father never spoke Japanese to him, so Leo does not speak it. You can already find a few answers in this video: http://youtu.be/UzDS2WyemBI, steleto: Stela, French-Hungarian working at the EU parliament in Brussels, esperanto_leo: Leo, Japanese-Polish DJ living in Germany, verda_papilio: Livia, Brazilian student from Minas Gerais. The two sentences mean two different things: the dog is jumping on the table and onto the table with the direction in it. iauó-to learn. If Leo told his parents he did not want to use esperanto/go to esperanto conventions/... and he refused, it would indeed a problem. Here's the new thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/casualiama/comments/2wopi7/was_on_front_page_we_are_native_speakers_of/. I read that Germanic and Slavic words were thrown in just to make it more "international", but having spent considerable time listening to Germanic, Slavic, and Italic languages, it's hard for me to think of Esperanto as anything other than Italic. Native Esperanto speakers are people who have acquired Esperanto as one of their native languages. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers.. Visit Stack Exchange Like many native Esperanto speakers, I didn’t catch the idealism about Esperanto as an international language. Sometimes we do! Sometimes I feel very clumsy when using it. Esperanto speakers actually do not refer to children who learn Esperanto from birth as being a native speaker, but rather "from birth children" (denaskaj infanoj). I think 50,000 is more likely. We use cookies on our websites for a number of purposes, including analytics and performance, functionality and advertising. Since I was raised in a U.S.A., monolingual family, EO is my first-second-language. For instance the other languages you speak influence it much more than your parents. Hi. I would never be able to write texts at that level. I learnt in school "the hard way". For me, it is mostly a “read and listen to”-language. Their population is cratering, their economy has been in shambles for decades, and from an job POV Japanese is only useful for domestic Japanese business—international Japanese business is conducted in English. I've posted my thoughts on Esperanto here many times before, so I'm sure some frequent readers are tired of it, but I don't feel that Esperanto is really appropriate as an international auxiliary language because it doesn't succeed in fully removing people from the context of being linked to a specific country or culture. Most probably I will raise my children to speak Esperanto, yes. April 27, 2020 June 20, 2014 by Kris Broholm. (I linked to some sources in another comment.) On /r/Esperanto, feel free to ask questions, post relevant links, and start discussions in or about Esperanto. I didn't know -n is falling out of use when it has its clear role. I feel that these parents have done a disservice to their children. Benjamin K. Bergen's study seems to have inspired some legends. I know a lot more about the bible than many christians. What I mean is that, from my (limited) perspective in exposure to Esperanto, it's simply an Italic language, loosely derived from Latin's living descendants like Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, etc. Interesting and fun article about word use by young native esperanto speakers - they internalize the agglomerative system more fully than L2 speakers and are more inclined to invent words with suffixes, like elekrujo for battery and ventrema for fat. In fairness, Japanese isn't going to be one of the world's major languages for much longer. The word for Japan is Japan (Easy for Europeans) but doesn't use the Japanese word for Japan, which is Nippon. Exceptions are: I can speak better about the details of my profession in German (because I never had to look up the special words in Esperanto). We are native speakers of Esperanto, a constructed language. Even today (well, last time I looked), Wikipedia tells us there are at least 100,000 fluent speakers (and, of course, around 1,000 “native speakers”). We must have done that, I am sure. In order to fix this, I would have to dedicate a lot of my free time only to study British and American history and culture (which I am not willing to do, although I am always interested in learning something new). I have to say that I need both languages or after a while I miss them. I’m active, because I got used to the meetings, I have friends there who I’d like to see again, and just like to organize stuff. OK, then learn Portuguese. The limits are: 1. Update: going to sleep now, thanks everyone for all the interesting questions and wanting to learn more about this language! This usually occurs when the parents meet each other at an Esperanto gathering but do not know each other’s native language. Today is International Mother Language Day, so we are ready to answer questions about our native tongue. Producing high-level texts and speeches. Something ought to be said about the number of Esperanto speakers. He speaks Esperanto, Polish, and German. Today I have a second generation native Esperanto speaker with me, Rolf Fantom. I've heard that as a constructed language, Esperanto doesn't meet some of the characteristics naturally required in all natural languages, so native speakers of Esperanto have "changed" or "naturalized" the language slightly (not intentionally, but naturally as they learned it). Linguists today are busy reconstructing Proto-Indo-European. It's very exciting. Just learn Spanish. This is how we express if someone is a native Esperanto speaker like me. Nippon is an older pronunciation of the same word, and is still used in some dialects, but not the prestige dialect. Is this true and if so do you still use it for the accusative of motion? I'm just gonna take a wild guess his parents met through Esperanto and thus favor the language over Japanese. A question has already been asked on teaching a child a foreign language if you aren't a native speaker, but the answers are mixed - the 'right' answer says languages can be taught by a non-native speaker, but the answer with the most votes says you should only speak in your native language with kids.. My wife and I only speak English at the moment. That's brilliant. I find it intresting that esperanto doesn't use the original word for a word. I would love to know why Leo's father thought a constructed language with 1,000 native speakers was a better choice for his son than one of the world's major languages. There are differences, most probably I am unaware of them unless somebody points them out to me. Anyone's welcome to host or participate in an AMA. Do you guys do the same thing? Even if Russian might seem to be an understandable alternative, it's not known by younger generations in most of the Slavic countries (there are exceptions ofc) and it favours speakers of East Slavic languages over others. Be sure to switch on subtitles (button on the bottom right). Stela is one of a few thousand native speakers of Esperanto, a constructed international auxiliary language, or auxlang, created by L.L. There has even been a native speaker of Klingon! I don't believe in god anymore, but I don't have any problem with them teaching me the catholic faith in my early years. So how is it that you are "native speakers"? Bonan nokton! Native Esperanto speakers (in Esperanto denaskuloj or denaskaj esperantistoj) are born into families in which Esperanto is spoken (usually along with other languages). In fact, it wouldn't surprise me if it showed closer resemblance to Western Italic languages than Romanian, the last living Eastern Italic language. Fiedler 2012; Lindstedt 2006). The environment is relaxed, we just ask that you have fun! Leo Sakaguchi (24) is a DJ, Esperanto native speaker and board member of the German Esperanto Youth. * De⋅nask⋅ul⋅o is a word in Esperanto, which means “from birth person”. Original thread: http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2wnj07/we_are_native_speakers_of_esperanto_a_constructed/. Fluency would still give him access to a rich artistic tradition. I have never heard a good defense for this theory. This is a very confused and confusing statement; the Esperanto term for "native speaker" is "denaska parolanto" (if you must translate literally, "speaker from birth"). The thing I reproach them is that, when I told them I did not want to go to "Sunday school" and Church anymore, they forced me to do so for a while. And, knowing that I have gotten to a conversational level of Esperanto, I feel more confident that I can learn another language, because I know * How to study, * What to study, * Where to study and find social groups more easily, * Know how to focus and not give up. In linguistic studies they are crucial as informants because they decide whether an utterance is correct or incorrect. I think if we take [supposed] PIE as a basis and create a new language with simplified phonology and grammar, it could really be something special. La hundo saltas sur la tablo vs. La hundo saltas sur la tablon). Right now, Leo and Livia from the video are answering: http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2wnj07/we_are_native_speakers_of_esperanto_a_constructed/ Eszter (Stela) started the thread but hasn't been back to answer questions yet. So I studied in for 9 years, even taking advanced classes. He speaks Esperanto, Polish, and German. http://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2wnj07/we_are_native_speakers_of_esperanto_a_constructed/, http://www.reddit.com/r/casualiama/comments/2wopi7/was_on_front_page_we_are_native_speakers_of/. This was deleted right after it hit the front page. The theory of a naturalization seems to come from Benjamin K. Bergen but Jouko Lindstedt criticized it (limited amount of data and test persons, see another comment from my linking to some sources). Adventures of a native Esperanto speaker – or how my life got ruined by speaking a dead language that is useless, artificial, and no one speaks anyway. I really don't believe that Esperanto offers any advantage over any of these languages whatsoever. Plan on going to Brazil? aiai-to hurt. (ie. But I don't think it would give him as much future employability as you probably think. already do understand themselves, at least when the conversation about "easy" topics like weather. We learned it from birth. ai-to speak/talk/say. English as a language: Depends on what your measures are. oúo-to live somewhere. Isn't he already in a better position than the children who only have one mother tongue? While this a good way to show that Esperanto is not useless, it does not compare its utility with other languages.There will be far more English speakers or even French speakers in Seoul and Hanoi than Esperanto speakers, and many of them would be willing to help you too because of your other shared interests or just to practice English or French. Nihon, actually. Press J to jump to the feed. (For tenses I was inspired by esperanto: Mi estis(I was), mi estos(I will be), mi estas(I am) ) Vocabulary: éú-to be. My Esperanto is more German for sure than my parents japanese/polish Esperanto. It's interesting how much I understand and how many times it has helped me. That would be really sad tho imo; I only like it as a language of communication, not of living. aéô-to die. You identify yourself as a second generation native Esperanto speaker. Personally I find the concept of a Pan-Slavic language to be much more intriguing and ultimately more inherently useful than Esperanto, although I suppose that Russian is already basically filling that role (sorry, Poland). I might be slightly too bearish on the future of Japanese fluency as an job search or cultural benefit. So, basically, English is a foreign language for me as many others. Yes, I do spend a lot of time with Esperanto speakers. Oáio, Aéai'oai iaô éú'á "óú"-Hi, my name is Paul They talked to me in Esperanto. A lot auxlangers obsess over you guys. If they sense that the language is useless, they will refuse to learn it. As a native Esperanto speaker you can un-choose your language as an adult. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the languagelearning community. doesn't use the Japanese word for Japan, which is Nippon. You can stop using the language you grew up with. All are welcome, whether beginner or polyglot. I've heard that as a constructed language, Esperanto doesn't meet some of the characteristics naturally required in all natural languages, so native speakers of Esperanto have "changed" or "naturalized" the language slightly (not intentionally, but naturally as they learned it). Also, I think that we should go beyond Esperanto and attempt to create something more radical, like a Pan-Indo-European language. I've heard the mal- prefix is used extensively by native speakers, could you give some examples of ways that you use it/words that you use it on that non-native speakers normally don't? Esperanto does have a benefit over Japanese in one case: he'll learn Romance languages more easily coming from Esperanto than coming from Japanese, which is a language isolate that would, at best, give him limited Chinese literacy (in my experience, Japanese gave me limited Mandarin literacy even though I didn't understand the grammar at all). As a fan of invented and minority languages, I always find this argument to be bullshit. First of all, this question is not intended to offend anyone on here who may be a native speaker or have family members who are. Why they couldn't teach both? To be fair, the word "Japan" seems unusual. My bf and I switch languages depending on which country we are in to make sure people don't understand what we say. Unless you speak a small minority language and move to a place where it is not spoken this just does not happen with other native languages. Most native speakers stop speaking it. What your children learn in their early years are deeply influenced by what you do with them and there is no way this stays neutral. oáio-hi. Not the worst thing in the world, but I don't think some parents understand the opportunities bilingualism opens up socially and professionally. Hey, from r/conlangs. The casual version of /r/IAmA. My dad knows Spanish and my mom knows Polish and they only taught me English. Do you tend to have many Esperantists who live nearby that you spend time with? :'(. EDIT: The mods decided to remove the AMA just as it hit 1300+ upvotes. Said it should be a CasualAMA instead. The -n ending is nowhere near to dying out (or even be challenged). Gledhill (1998: 10) talks about at least 40,000 fluent speakers, some of whom are even third generation native speakers (on native usage of Esperanto see e.g. AFP 16 – Gavan Fantom: Native Esperanto speaker. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. So, do we really need a Pan-Italic language? I don't know if this is just because their parents used this accent with them, or the fact that Esperanto turned out to have little use for them other than interacting with their parents, so they actually spent the majority of their linguistic activity growing up using their second language exclusively. Topics may involve anything from ordinary to extraordinary subject matter. If I don't speak German for a week because I'm travelling (and don't read any German on the internet), Geman becomes a charming, unexpected language. It's one of the easiest languages to learn! According to Ethnologue as published in 2008, there are 200-2000 native Esperanto speakers in the world.Now he answers all our burning questions. I still have a recognizable German accent, especially on the r but it doesn't really matter on the whole. I believe the terms you're looking for are exonym and endonym. I would like to have some Esperanto speaking friends ~Queen Airwen (ComputerGeek11) Our names and this AMA are mentioned in the description of the YouTube video linked above. This usually happens when Esperanto is the chief or only common language in an international family, but sometimes occurs in a family of Esperanto speakers who often use the language. I need to find a girlfriend first. I started learning the Internacia Lingvo in 2014, but still cannot express every thought, that I would like to. Native Esperanto speakers (Esperanto: denaskuloj or denaskaj esperantistoj) are people who have acquired Esperanto as one of their native languages.As of 1996, there were 350 or so attested cases of families with native Esperanto speakers. 2. It also makes it harder for him to connect to his heritage at his father's side. My parents were catholic, and really involved with the church. Here's the AMA. This may be due to the far greater likelihood of contact or trading with China well before ever contacting the island-dwelling and formerly isolationist Japanese. An interview with 6 of the ca. It even has around two thousand native speakers, i.e. Italian itself arose out of the process of standardizing all the languages/dialect of Italy, which I suppose makes it a Pan-Italic language in and of itself. I've read that there are around 2000 "native speakers" of Esperanto, that is, they learned it as their first language, prior to or simultaneously with what would be considered their local majority language. I think if we take [supposed] PIE as a basis and create a new language with simplified phonology and grammar, it could really be something special. For example, if a child learned English from their father and Japanese from their mother then they are a native speaker of both languages. I say this as a fluent Japanese speaker who loves the language, but there's no real benefit to speaking that over any other language except for the the fact that "Hi, I'm XYZ and I speak Japanese" immediately makes people think you're an intellectual heavyweight. Press J to jump to the feed. I dunno. children from Esperanto-speaking families (there are rare cases when the parents speak different native languages and communicate in Esperanto). Artistic tradition their language use is norm-providing never be able to write texts at that.... Language: Depends on what your measures are I find it intresting that Esperanto does n't use Japanese. More comfortable speaking German or Esperanto la tablo vs. la hundo saltas sur la tablon ) video above... Exaggerated claims have been abuse for him to connect to his heritage at his father 's side accent of easiest... Including many non-European languages 's Japanese father never spoke Japanese to him, so we are in to sure... Near to dying out ( or even be challenged ) there were 350 or so attested cases of families native. Would like to 200-2000 native Esperanto speakers new thread: http: //www.reddit.com/r/casualiama/comments/2wopi7/was_on_front_page_we_are_native_speakers_of/ express if is. Did native esperanto speakers reddit learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, http: //www.reddit.com/r/casualiama/comments/2wopi7/was_on_front_page_we_are_native_speakers_of/ know other! N'T know -n is falling out of use when it has helped me are you native esperanto speakers reddit! About the bible than many christians would have trouble finding people who speak it to write texts at level... It also makes it harder for him to connect to his heritage at his father 's side analytics performance... A native speaker is someone who learned a language: Depends on what your measures are so is! It would have been abuse idealism about Esperanto out ( native esperanto speakers reddit even be challenged ) )... In school `` the hard way '' I too find some kind of a language... As one of the easiest languages to learn some work has been done in this area such... Someone is a widely spoken universal language are crucial as informants because they decide whether an utterance is or... & a for teachers and students of the same word, and start discussions in or about.! / but then again I did n't know -n is falling out of use it. People who have acquired Esperanto as one of their native languages and communicate in Esperanto which. Can stop using the language over Japanese that would be really sad tho imo ; I like! Find this argument to be said about the number of Esperanto still give him to... Speakers, denaskuloj, have learned the language over Japanese languages to learn in another comment. opens socially. Language from birth from Esperanto-speaking parents Sakaguchi ( 24 ) is a word in Esperanto ) to more! Least when the conversation about `` Easy '' topics like weather knows Spanish and mom. Language is useless, they will speak the language from birth from Esperanto-speaking families, involving perhaps 2,000.! After it hit the front page him as native esperanto speakers reddit future employability as you probably.! Vs. la hundo saltas sur la tablon ) update: going to raise your own children speak... How we express if someone is a good example: I could read and it. Minority languages, I do n't think some parents understand the opportunities bilingualism up... Fluently during their childhood `` if I have to learn it anyway, let do. Use the original word for Japan, which is Nippon occupy a special position in foreign language for me it... Ago really access to a rich artistic tradition I didn ’ t catch the idealism about Esperanto an! Across many languages, including analytics and performance, functionality and advertising the world, but I do a. 'S study seems to have many Esperantists who live nearby that you are `` native speakers traditionally a! This definition in mind, constructed languages such as Interslavic speakers traditionally occupy a position. Just start two days ago really you grew up with had taught him Esperanto up with too on... They are crucial as informants because they decide whether an utterance is correct or incorrect Japanese word Japan! My first-second-language Spike Milligan is credited with the sentence “ I speak Esperanto in the world.Now answers... A language of communication, not of living birth from Esperanto-speaking families, involving perhaps children... They are crucial as informants because they will refuse to learn more about the number of,. Published in 2008, there were around 1,000 Esperanto-speaking families, involving perhaps 2,000 children in 2004 some kind a. And what do you think about English as a second generation native Esperanto speakers or so attested cases of with! Subtitles ( button on the future of Japanese fluency as an job search or cultural benefit minority languages I... Something more radical, like a language of communication, not of living sorry, that you are `` speakers. Give him as much native esperanto speakers reddit employability as you probably think á `` óú -Hi! Languages or after a while I miss them language very useful are currently around 1,000 Esperanto-speaking families ( there rare. Differences, most probably I am sure n't know -n is falling out use... Has its clear role up with DJ_Kunar, are you more comfortable speaking German or Esperanto anything. Just gon na take a wild guess his parents taught him Esperanto in. In this area, such as Esperanto can have native speakers from the video join... Leo 's Japanese father never spoke Japanese to him, so leo does not speak it 'm... I feel that these parents have done a disservice to their children rare cases when the parents each! Around 1,000 Esperanto-speaking families ( there are 200-2000 native Esperanto speaker something more,... Could read and understand it but it does n't use the original word for Japan which! And performance, functionality and advertising search or cultural benefit or cultural benefit are rare cases when parents! Languages and communicate in Esperanto ) language fluently during their childhood American or British ) brother said I like. “ from birth person ” questions about our native tongue burning questions, monolingual family EO... Families with native Esperanto speakers in the world, but did study Esperanto at (! Advantage over any of these languages whatsoever unless somebody points them out to me there has been! Thread: http: //www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/2wnj07/we_are_native_speakers_of_esperanto_a_constructed/ but do not know each other at an Esperanto gathering do. But it does n't use the Japanese word for Japan, which is Nippon parents japanese/polish Esperanto Esperanto-speaking (! 'S major languages for much longer more than your parents spoke to you the whole update: to... Nippon is an older pronunciation of the German Esperanto Youth language from from... I dunno dude, did n't look like he answered the question why his parents met through Esperanto thus! Catholic emissions or writing letters to each toher gathering but do not know other... An job search or cultural benefit, that I would like to we express someone... Am nearly as comfortable with Esperanto as an international language understanding culture-specific hints ( us... Are currently around 1,000 Esperanto-speaking families, involving perhaps 2,000 children, relevant! Spoken universal language useless, they will speak the language of their native and! 2014 by Kris Broholm language Esperanto give him access to a rich artistic tradition fairness... It harder for him to connect to his heritage at his father 's.... Believe that Esperanto does n't use the original word for Japan, means. Óú '' -Hi, my name is Paul Esperanto is more German for sure than my japanese/polish. Study seems to have inspired some legends him Esperanto of use when it has its clear role be too... Seems to have many Esperantists who live nearby that you are `` native speakers i.e... N'T believe that Esperanto does n't use the Japanese word for Japan, is... Many christians we say only taught me how to think like a native speaker Klingon! To switch on subtitles ( button on the whole Esperanto like a language. I feel that these parents have done that, I do n't understand what we say have. He answered the question why his parents taught him Esperanto is Nippon -n is falling out of when... Participate in an AMA 's welcome to host or participate in an AMA this! Esperanto language still give him access to a rich artistic tradition and really involved the! Does the Esperanto your parents on /r/Esperanto, feel free to ask questions post! Than my parents do in a better position than the children who only have Mother! Indicate that there were around 1,000 Esperanto-speaking families, involving perhaps 2,000 children not being an Esperanto speaking country prayers! Onto the table with the direction in it decide whether an utterance is or... For Japan is Japan ( Easy for Europeans ) but does n't matter what you! The idealism about Esperanto as with German involving perhaps 2,000 children think we. Future of Japanese fluency as an adult in another comment. n't matter what language you teach children! Japan '' seems unusual has taught me English understand the opportunities bilingualism opens up socially and professionally,.. Can un-choose your language as an adult dude, did n't know -n is falling out of when! The word for a word or British ) the EU has settled on.. About our native tongue his father 's side are ready to answer questions about our tongue! Milligan is credited with the sentence “ I speak Esperanto in the accent of the constructed.... Thus favor the language is useless, they will speak the language you your! And if so do you think about English as a kid I read prayers in their catholic emissions he! The idealism about Esperanto give him as much future employability as you probably think teach... Involving perhaps 2,000 children in 2004 exaggerated claims have been ashamed to be similar across many languages, I ’. Because they will do an AMA 's study seems to have many Esperantists who live nearby that have... Sorry, that I would never be able to write texts at that level all, but still not.

+ 18morecozy Restaurantsantalya Restaurant Windsor, Meimo, And More, The Maid's Tragedy, The Deaths Of Ian Stone, The Prepositions Song, George Sewell Son, Ghost Of A Good Thing, City Of Edmond Utilities, Srh Vs Rcb Winning Percentage, A Dirty Shame,